Carrier Contact Information
Billing:800-842-5075
Claims: 800-252-4633
www.travelers.com
Billing: 800-735-3284
Claims: 866-455-9969
www.selective.com
Claims: 1-877-776-2436
www.progressive.com
Service: 800-527-3905
Claims:800-527-3907
www.foremost.com
We have merged!
Effective October 3rd, 2025 Carolina's Choice merged with Compass Insurance. We are excited to meet and assist in all your insurance needs. Max, Nicci, Diane, and Keisha are all still with the agency.